• Pierre,
    You use the axle detection method in conjunction with TrainController software. At this moment, I have no intention to use PC control for my layout, just walkaround NCE PowerCab DCC. Could I apply the axle detection method in another way i.e. non-PC control? If so, how? I am interested to use some (reasonable cost) approach of detecting track occupancy esp for hidden tracks.

    • The axle detection is of course optional: for many people, detecting the locomotive will be enough. Maybe you should not worry about it (I worry about personally because I want to be 100% sure to detect “lost cars” in my hidden station).

      To answer your question: of course, any method that transforms the axles into a “resistor” consuming a little power will work as long as you are using “power usage” based detectors. There are other methods of course (magnet or Infrared-based), but these I really wouldn’t advise. In any case: detecting power from locos or resistive axles does not limit you in terms of “where” the detection signal goes.

      What you would need is a simple “power consumption detector”, that does not deliver its result to a “feedback bus” (such as S88 or Loconet), but rather visually (integrated LEDs) or to simple “on/off” connectors (to which you can connect LEDs, or even later an actual S88/Loconet module). An example I know is http://www.conrad.com/ce/en/product/217326/21-01-026-Electronic-track-busy-reporting-GBM-1-4-x-component/?ref=detview1&rt=detview1&rb=1 but this is a kit you need to solder yourself. You need to look around, especially if you’re not in Europe. There are probably many similar and even cheaper devices out there.

      • As I plan to run long trains, I thought of the idea of having axle detection. Half of my trackage is by design hidden; hence, some form of detection would help me note their position. I am not planning to use any PC-based control, thus, a visual indicator – either at side panel of each module or at a CTC panel would be needed.

        Initially I thought of the photodetector but I read it does not work well.

        Thanks for the Conrad link. I will evaluate the kit.

        P/S: I am now living in Frankfurt, Germany.

Subscribe to the LocGeek Newsletter

Subscribe to the LocGeek Newsletter

Never miss a model railroading update, subscribe to the LocGeek newsletter.

1 email per month top, unsubscribe anytime!

Great! Now check your inbox or spam folder to validate and finalize your subscription!

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

Cookies are used to give you the best experience on the site. Cookies are files stored in your browser and are used by most websites to help personalise your web experience. By continuing to use our website without changing the settings on the disclaimer page, you are accepting cookies as described on the same page.